Parents question whether shooting drills traumatize kids

Lockdown backlash: How do schools prepare for the worst without terrorizing students?


Make text smaller Make text larger



Photos



  • “The Last Lockdown,” a series of ten sculptures distributed across the country, were inspired by the school massacre in Parkland, Fla., on Feb. 14, 2018. Sculptors Dan Crumrine and Sean Leonard collaborated with Manuel Oliver, who lost his son, Joaquin, in the shooting. “We created something that can stand as a galvanizing symbol of what students living in the ‘lockdown generation’ are fighting against,” they write. (Photo: commarts.com)



“To me, this just seems like an indirect admission on the part of the schools that they really have no control over who gets into the building, and the school security officer isn't enough to keep the place safe so we need to hold the kids accountable for doing it."
Nanette Adams, parent, Bethel Park, Pa.


By Carolyn Thompson

Long before an ex-student opened fire on his former classmates in Parkland, Florida, many school districts conducted regular shooting drills — exercises that sometimes included simulated gunfire and blood and often happened with no warning that the attack wasn't real.

The drills began taking shape after the Columbine High School shooting in 1999. But 20 years later, parents are increasingly questioning elements of the practice, including whether the drills traumatize kids.

April Sullivan was pleasantly surprised by an “I love you, Mom" text from her daughter last May, even though she knew the eighth-grader wasn't supposed to be using her cellphone during school in Short Pump, Virginia. But she did not know that her child sent it while supposedly hiding from an intruder. The girl didn't know the “code blue" alert was a drill.

“To find out later she sent that text because she was in fear for her life did not sit well with me," Sullivan said.

Henrico County Public Schools have since changed the way they conduct drills, making clear at the start that the events are not real and notifying parents as the drill begins or right after, district spokesman Andy Jenks said.

Backlash underlines challengesThe backlash underlines the challenges administrators face in deciding how far to go in the name of preparedness.

Thirty-nine states require lockdown, active-shooter or similar safety drills. Other states have less explicit requirements or leave it to districts, according to the Education Commission of the States. A Mississippi task force has proposed twice-yearly active-shooter drills.

But even as the drills become routine for many of the nation's 51 million elementary and secondary public school students, there is no consensus on how they should be conducted, experts said. No data exists, for example, to show whether a drill with simulated gunfire is more effective or whether an exercise that's been announced in advance is taken less seriously than a surprise.

“Some hard data on each question are needed with urgency," said University at Buffalo professor Jeremy Finn, who gathered experts from around the country to evaluate school security measures at a conference in Washington, D.C., in October.

After Columbine, lockdowns that involved bolting the door and crouching quietly out of sight became the norm. In 2013, the Department of Education recommended giving staff latitude to evacuate, barricade classroom doors or, as a last resort, fight back by throwing things or rushing the attacker.

“Do you really want it to be your kid who's the one who takes the bullet and winds up with a plaque in the lobby of the school saying he went down as a hero?" asked Bethel Park, Pennsylvania, parent Nanette Adams, who disagreed with the decision to adopt a widely used safety protocol during a September drill at her 15-year-old son's high school. The protocol is known as ALICE, which stands for alert, lockdown, inform, counter and evacuate.

“To me, this just seems like an indirect admission on the part of the schools that they really have no control over who gets into the building, and the school security officer isn't enough to keep the place safe so we need to hold the kids accountable for doing it," she said.

'Physical and psychological harm'In 2014, the National Association of School Psychologists and the National Association of School Resource Officers issued joint guidance that cautioned that while drills have the potential to save lives, those “not conducted appropriately" can cause “physical and psychological harm to students, staff and the overall learning environment."

After public criticism of the unannounced Short Pump drill and others, the Virginia House of Delegates last month considered, but defeated, legislation requiring schools to give parents advance notification. The bill's Democratic sponsor, Schuyler VanValkenburg, a high school teacher, said opponents argued that the heads-up would hinder safety by letting students take it less seriously.

“I think that's baloney. They're very aware of what can happen in this day and age. They all see the news. They all see social media," said Sullivan, whose daughter declined to be interviewed by The Associated Press but described the drill for Richmond television station WWBT a few days later.

“I thought I was probably going to die that day," she said. “We hear the door handle jiggling up and down and then we see the door open, and it's our resource officer telling us it's a drill."

When her son's school fired blanks during a drill, Adams questioned whether it was really necessary to expose children to the sound of gunfire. Others complained that such realistic exercises can take a toll on classroom learning even after the drills are done.

Mo Canady, executive director of the school resource officers' group, recommends districts save the most intense exercises for staff only. As the decision-makers, he said, “they need to know a little more what that's going to feel like."

For students, lower-stress drills that have them listening to instructions and running through the motions, like traditional fire drills, should be the focus, he said.

“We need to be as prepared as we can," Canady said, “but it doesn't mean that we've got to terrify students to get them prepared."





Make text smaller Make text larger

Comments

Pool Rules



MUST READ NEWS

Lackawaxen VFW to hold Memorial Day chicken barbecue
The Lackawaxen VFW Post 5635 is holding its annual Memorial Day chicken barbecue from 1 to 4 p.m. on Sunday, May 26.
The menu includes a half-chicken, potato salad, three-bean...

Read more »
Image

Spend time in cars? Don't forget skin protection
For most people, car safety means seat belts and airbags. But there's another important way to stay safe on the road, and that's by protecting your skin from the sun.
A study...

Read more »
Image

Church group offers political primary day luncheon

MILFORD – The Women’s Association of the Evangelical Presbyterian Church of Milford (EPC) will be holding a Primary Election Day Soup and Sandwich Luncheon on...

Read more »
Image

ESU to launch region's only graduate program in accounting
Pennsylvania State System of Higher Education Chancellor Daniel Greenstein approved a master’s degree in accounting for East Stroudsburg University of...
Read more »
Image

VIDEOS



Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required
Community Newspapers



MOST READ

Local News
Combining Brewing and Farming
  • May 17, 2019

MOST COMMENTED



Weather in Milford, PA